Is the Climax Series Fair?

The pennant winner missed the Japan Series in 8 of 39 Final Stages. The race for third ended within one game in 8 of 38 league-seasons.

Why critics call it unfair

Scroll right for more

Item Count Out of Cases
Pennant winner missed the Japan Series 8 39 Final Stages 2007 Central Chunichi (seed 2), 2010 Pacific Lotte (seed 3), 2014 Central Hanshin (seed 2), 2017 Central DeNA (seed 3), 2018 Pacific SoftBank (seed 2), 2019 Pacific SoftBank (seed 2), 2024 Central DeNA (seed 3), 2026 Central DeNA (seed 3)
Entered with a sub-.500 record 7 clubs (0 reached the Japan Series) 116 entries 2009 Yakult, 2013 Hiroshima, 2015 Hanshin, 2016 DeNA, 2018 Yomiuri, 2021 Yomiuri, 2022 Hanshin
Overturned against a gap of 10+ games 3 22 matchups with a 10+ game gap 2008 Central First Hanshin → Chunichi (11-win gap), 2017 Central Final Hiroshima → DeNA (15-win gap), 2021 Central First Hanshin → Yomiuri (16-win gap)

In 4 of the times the pennant winner lost, the third-place club went to the Japan Series.

The 2007 Final Stage was played without an advantage for the champion.

Advertisements

Why supporters call it necessary

Scroll right for more

Item Count Out of Cases
Third and fourth within one game 8 league-seasons 38 league-seasons 2008 Pacific, 2010 Pacific, 2011 Pacific, 2012 Pacific, 2013 Pacific, 2015 Central, 2019 Central, 2022 Central

Clubs that beat the pennant winner to reach the Japan Series went on to win it 5 of 7 times.

Advertisements
Advertisements

Related articles