Early Baseball Was "First to 21 Runs"
For modern baseball fans, the "9-inning format" is taken for granted, but under the early rules of baseball, the length of a game was decided not by the number of innings but by runs. Under the Knickerbocker Rules, said to have been drawn up by Alexander Cartwright in 1845, the rule was that the first team to score 21 runs (then called "aces") won. There was no limit on the number of innings, and the game continued until 21 runs were reached. This "first-to-score format" had the problem that games could become extremely long or extremely short. In games between teams with strong pitching, it took dozens of innings to reach 21 runs, while games between teams with strong hitting ended in just a few innings. The unpredictability of game length was a major obstacle for baseball as a commercial spectacle.
The Turning Point of 1857 - The Birth of the "9-Inning Format"
In 1857, at a convention of the National Association of Base Ball Players (NABBP), the change from the first-to-21-runs format to the 9-inning format was decided. The main motive for this change was to standardize game length. Under a 9-inning format, the length of a game would fit roughly within 2 to 3 hours, and both spectators and players could approach games on a predictable schedule. Why was it "9" innings? There are various theories about this, but the most widely accepted one is the idea of "the number of innings that lets 9 players each come to bat once". To ensure that each of a team's 9 batters could come to the plate at least 3 times in a game, 9 innings was appropriate. 9 players × 3 plate appearances = 27 plate appearances. This matches the calculation that each batter comes to the plate an average of 3 times in 9 innings. However, no official record supporting this theory survives, and the exact reason "9" was chosen remains lost in the mists of history.
The 7-Inning Debate - A Trump Card for Shortening Games
In recent years, as shortening game times has become a global issue in baseball, the introduction of a "7-inning format" is sometimes debated. In MLB, during the 2020 COVID-19 pandemic season, doubleheader games were played under a 7-inning format. The 7-inning format had the effect of shortening game time by about 30 minutes, and it helped reduce the burden on players and made doubleheaders easier to hold. However, there is strong opposition to permanently adopting a 7-inning format. The belief that "9 innings is the essence of baseball" runs deep, and there is much criticism that a 7-inning format is "not real baseball". In NPB, there has been almost no debate about a 7-inning format, but as longer game times are seen as a problem, the debate may surface in the future.
Innings in Amateur Baseball - A World Where 7 Innings Is the Standard
Professional baseball uses a 9-inning format, but the 7-inning format is widely adopted in amateur baseball. American high school baseball uses a 7-inning format, while college baseball uses a 9-inning format. Japanese high school baseball (Koshien) uses a 9-inning format, but some regional tournaments may adopt a 7-inning format. In youth baseball, 6-inning and 5-inning formats are also common. The reason amateur baseball adopts a 7-inning format is to take into account the physical burden on players (especially pitchers). Forcing players who are still growing to play 9-inning games leads to excessive strain on their shoulders and elbows. The 7-inning format works as a compromise that balances the completeness of the sport with the health of the players.
The Chance and Necessity of the Number "9"
In baseball, "9" appears in several elements in common: the number of players (9), the number of innings (9), and the fielding positions (9). This is not a coincidence but the result of the 9-player format being decided first, with the number of innings and the fielding positions designed to match it. However, no clear basis survives for why it was "9 players" either. In early baseball, games were sometimes played with 8 or 10 players, and 9 players became the standard between the 1840s and the 1850s. According to one theory, it is said that the number of members of club teams at the time, which was around 9, had an influence. In other words, it is highly likely that baseball's "9" is a product of historical chance rather than a logical necessity. Yet the "9", which has been maintained without change for more than 170 years, has gone beyond chance and is now built into baseball's DNA.
Will the 9-Inning Format Last Forever?
Will the day ever come when baseball's 9-inning format is changed? As of August 2026, there is no concrete move to change the 9-inning format in professional baseball. However, looking back on the history of baseball, there are many examples of rules once thought to be "unchangeable" being changed. The introduction of the DH, the introduction of replay review, the introduction of the automatic intentional walk, and the introduction of the pitch clock. All of them were criticized as "damaging the essence of baseball", yet in the end they were accepted. The 9-inning format, too, could become a target for change if the pressure to shorten game times grows high enough. However, changing the 9-inning format is on a different level from other rule changes. 9 innings is the very identity of baseball, and changing it cannot escape the criticism that it would "make baseball no longer baseball". The 1857 decision to switch from the first-to-21-runs format to the 9-inning format was one of the most important rule changes in the history of baseball. If a change of equal weight were made next, it would mean a fundamental redefinition of the sport of baseball.