The Conditions for a "Winning Pitcher" Are Absurd - The Contradictions and Unfairness of the 5-Inning Rule

The Conditions for a Winning Pitcher - 5 Innings for a Starter, "Most Effective" for a Reliever

Under the official scoring rules of NPB (and MLB), the winning pitcher is determined as follows. For a starting pitcher to become the winning pitcher, he must pitch at least 5 innings, leave the game with his team in the lead, and that lead must be held to the end. If the starting pitcher leaves before completing 5 innings, the official scorer awards the win to whichever reliever "pitched most effectively." This judgment of "most effective" is left to the scorer's subjective view, and there is no clear standard. The number 5 innings means the pitcher has thrown the majority of the game (5 of 9 innings), but it is highly questionable whether this standard accurately reflects a pitcher's contribution.

Advertisements

The Contradiction That a Pitcher Can Win Even After Allowing 10 Runs in 5 Innings

Let us consider an extreme example. A starting pitcher pitches 5 innings and allows 10 runs. His team's lineup, however, scores 11 runs, and the relievers hold the opponent scoreless over the remaining 4 innings. In this case, the winning pitcher is the starter who allowed 10 runs. That is because he met the condition of pitching 5 innings, and his team was leading when he left the game. Meanwhile, in another game, a starting pitcher holds the opponent scoreless for 4 2/3 innings but leaves before getting through the 5th. A reliever then pitches 1/3 of an inning to protect the lead, and the team wins. In this case, the scoreless starter gets no win, and the reliever who pitched only 1/3 of an inning may become the winning pitcher. The pitcher who allowed 10 runs wins, and the pitcher who allowed none cannot. This contradiction shows a fundamental flaw in the winning pitcher as a metric.

"Wins" Cannot Measure a Pitcher's Ability

In the world of sabermetrics, the number of wins is considered nearly worthless as a metric for measuring a pitcher's ability. To become the winning pitcher, a pitcher needs not only his own strong pitching but also run support from his lineup and the relievers holding the lead. In other words, wins depend not on the individual pitcher's ability but on the performance of the team as a whole. Starting pitchers on teams with strong lineups pile up wins, while starting pitchers on teams with weak lineups do not get wins even when they pitch well. Even for pitchers with the same 2.50 ERA, it commonly happens that one on a heavy-hitting team wins 15 games while one on a weak-hitting team wins 8. Now that metrics such as WAR (Wins Above Replacement) and FIP (Fielding Independent Pitching), which measure an individual pitcher's contribution more accurately, have been developed, the importance of the number of wins has declined significantly.

NPB Culture Still Values "Wins"

Even though sabermetrics has pointed out the limits of the number of wins, wins are still highly valued in NPB. The title for most wins is one of the most prestigious titles for a pitcher, and the number of wins is treated as an important metric in salary negotiations as well. Between "15 wins this season" and "5.0 WAR this season," the former is overwhelmingly easier to grasp for both fans and the media. The appeal of wins lies in their simplicity. "Won" or "lost." The clarity of this binary carries an intuitive persuasive power that complex statistical metrics lack. When a pitcher says "I want to win today," he does not mean that he wants to raise his WAR by 0.3. It is an emotional desire to contribute to the team's victory and to earn a win as proof of it. Wins may be an incomplete metric statistically, but perhaps a perfect one emotionally.

Advertisements

The Historical Background of the "5-Inning Rule"

The historical background to setting the starting pitcher's win condition at "5 innings or more" lies in the role of the starting pitcher in the baseball of the past. In the baseball of the first half of the 20th century, it was a matter of course for a starting pitcher to pitch a complete game, and hardly any pitchers left after 5 innings. The 5-inning rule was set as a standard of "at least this much should be pitched," and by the sensibilities of the time it was an extremely low hurdle. In today's baseball, however, the average number of innings pitched by starters has fallen to 5 to 6, and the 5-inning rule has become a standard of "whether he can just barely reach it." In an era when 100-pitch limits have become common and it is not unusual for a starting pitcher to leave after 4 2/3 innings, the 5-inning rule has to be called an outdated standard.

Should the Winning Pitcher System Be Abolished?

Voices calling for the winning pitcher system to be abolished have grown stronger along with the spread of sabermetrics. If you ask whether abolition is realistic, though, the answer is probably no. Wins are deeply rooted in the history and culture of baseball, and figures such as 200 career wins and 20 wins in a season continue to function as yardsticks for measuring great feats in baseball. The number of wins is also included in the selection criteria for the Sawamura Award. The contradictions of the winning pitcher system show that baseball's system of records is based not on "perfect fairness" but on "historical custom." Just as RBIs do not accurately reflect an individual batter's ability, wins do not accurately reflect an individual pitcher's ability. Both, however, are indispensable words for telling the story of baseball. Even if they are incomplete, wins will probably remain part of the language of baseball.

Advertisements