The Baseball Gambling Scandal - A Little-Known Side of NPB

Baseball Gambling by Yomiuri Players Comes to Light

In October 2015, it came to light that three Yomiuri Giants pitchers had been involved in baseball gambling. It was revealed that the three players, Shoki Kasahara, Tatsuya Matsumoto, and Satoshi Fukuda, had gambled on professional baseball games through acquaintances. The games they bet on included their own team's games, making it a grave scandal that shook the very foundation of NPB. The fact that Yomiuri players had taken part in baseball gambling sent shockwaves through the entire baseball world. All three players were declared indefinitely ineligible by NPB, which amounted in effect to a permanent ban.

Advertisements

Background and Structure of the Scandal

Behind the scandal lay problems with the players' social circles and their attitudes toward money. All three were young pitchers, and although they earned high salaries, they turned to gambling, an illegal act. The intermediary for the gambling was an acquaintance of the players, and it was pointed out that the management of the players' personal associations had been inadequate. Furthermore, professional baseball players making baseball games the object of gambling carries the risk of leading to match fixing. When a player bets on his own team's games, a motive to lose deliberately can arise, and the fairness of the games is threatened at its root. The three players' gambling is said to have been going on since around 2012, and the fact that it went undiscovered for a long time was also seen as a problem.

NPB's Response and Penalties

In response to the scandal, NPB declared the three players indefinitely ineligible. This was the heaviest penalty, equivalent to a permanent ban, and a severe measure not seen since the Black Mist Scandal. Yomiuri's supreme adviser at the time, Tsuneo Watanabe, acknowledged that "the club bears responsibility for supervision", and the club also took measures to prevent a recurrence. NPB instructed all clubs to strengthen anti-gambling education for players. In addition, an information-gathering system was put in place to identify inappropriate associations in players' private lives. Commissioner Katsuhiko Kumazaki stated that "we will do everything in our power to restore trust in professional baseball". Commissioner Katsuhiko Kumazaki was a former Prosecutor-General, and he drew on his experience as a legal expert to hand down strict penalties. At the press conference announcing the penalties, a policy of taking resolute measures to protect trust in professional baseball was set out.

Strengthening Anti-Gambling Measures and Remaining Challenges

After the scandal, NPB substantially strengthened its anti-gambling measures. Measures implemented included mandatory anti-gambling training for all players, the establishment of an external whistleblowing hotline, and stricter codes of conduct for players. In addition, digital literacy education was introduced to respond to the spread of online gambling via smartphones. However, completely preventing gambling is difficult. Online gambling is becoming more anonymous, and gambling using cryptocurrency is also increasing. In addition to institutional measures, NPB needs to continue education that raises players' ethical awareness and self-management skills. This scandal once again highlighted the seriousness of the gambling problem in professional sports.

Advertisements

Comparison with the Black Mist Scandal

In the Black Mist Scandal, which came to light between 1969 and 1971, several players, centered on the Nishitetsu Lions, received permanent bans for involvement in match fixing. The Black Mist Scandal differed in nature from the 2015 Yomiuri case in that direct ties with organized crime were the issue and it was match fixing that manipulated the game results themselves. In the Yomiuri case, no evidence of game manipulation was confirmed, but the players were severely condemned because the very fact of betting on their own team's games could become a breeding ground for match fixing. What the two scandals have in common is a structure in which points of contact between gambling and organized crime arise through players' private lives, and it became clear that the baseball world faces similar challenges even after half a century.

Common Ground with Gambling Problems in Other Sports

Baseball gambling is not a problem limited to professional baseball. In grand sumo, wrestlers' involvement in baseball gambling came to light in 2010, leading to a change in the way the Nagoya tournament was held. Overseas, Pete Rose of Major League Baseball received a permanent ban in 1989 for betting on his own team's games. In every one of these cases, the essence of the problem is that when competitors make their own sport the object of betting, the fairness of the competition is structurally undermined. The NPB scandal is one example of the gambling problem facing the sports world at home and abroad, and it showed the need to tackle it with both institutional prevention measures and player education. In countries where the legalization of sports betting is advancing, drawing the line between it and the illegal gambling that players get involved in has become an even more important issue.

Structural Flaws in Club Management

This scandal raised the question of how far a club should manage its players' private lives. Although Yomiuri is one of the wealthiest clubs in baseball, its grasp of information about its players' social circles was inadequate. As young players who had finished living in the dormitory built free social circles in urban areas, routes to contact with gambling intermediaries emerged. After the scandal, each club moved forward with assigning compliance officers and setting up external consultation desks, but how to strike a balance with players' privacy remains an ongoing point of debate. It came to be recognized that the balance between management and trust in club organizations is a challenge common to professional sports as a whole, and that simply strengthening surveillance does not provide a fundamental solution.

Advertisements