A Simple Question - Is It Wrong to Wear Gloves on Both Hands?
One of the simple questions people have when they watch baseball for the first time is "Why is the glove on only one hand?" With batted balls flying in at 150 km/h, isn't it dangerous to catch them one-handed? With gloves on both hands, the catching surface would double, and catching should become far more reliable. In fact, no rule explicitly prohibits wearing gloves on both hands. Yet in neither NPB nor MLB has a single player worn gloves on both hands. This is not an unwritten rule; it is because the movement structure of baseball as a sport makes the "one-hand glove" inevitable.
Reason 1 - You Must Throw Right After Catching
The most intuitive reason is that "you need to throw after catching." In baseball defense, catching and throwing come as a set. Field a grounder, and you throw to first. Catch a fly ball, and you return it to the cutoff man. Plays that end with the catch alone occur only in limited situations, such as catching a strikeout or the final out of an inning. If you wore gloves on both hands, after the catch you would have to take the ball out of the glove and then throw while still wearing a glove. Because you cannot throw accurately with a gloved hand, you would need time to remove one of the gloves. This loss of 0.5 to 1 second becomes a fatal difference that separates out from safe on an infield grounder.
Reason 2 - The Bare Hand Becomes the Glove's "Lid"
If you watch how players catch a baseball, at the moment the ball enters the glove they cover it with their bare hand (the throwing hand). This motion is called "putting the lid on," and it keeps the caught ball from popping out of the glove. Especially on hard-hit balls and grounders with irregular bounces, the glove alone sometimes cannot fully secure the ball. With the bare hand acting as a lid, catching becomes more reliable. If you wore gloves on both hands, you could not make this "lid" motion. Even pressing two gloves together cannot hold the ball down as delicately as a bare hand. In other words, having one bare hand does not lower catching reliability; if anything, it raises it.
Reason 3 - The History of the Glove Settled on "One Hand"
In the early days of baseball (the 1840s to 1860s), gloves did not exist. Players caught the ball with bare hands. Gloves appeared in the 1870s, and at first they were nothing more than thin leather gloves meant to reduce pain in the palm. At that point the glove was not "a tool dedicated to catching" but "protective gear for the hand," so wearing it on only one hand was a natural choice. There was no need to put protective gear on the throwing hand as well. Gloves then evolved to improve catching performance, adding the web (the netting) and the pocket (the hollow in the catching surface). As gloves grew larger, wearing one on the throwing hand became more and more impractical. A modern glove weighs about 500 to 600 grams, and wearing it on the throwing hand would greatly reduce the accuracy and speed of throws.
What Makes the First Baseman's Mitt Special - The Position Closest to "Catching Only"
The first baseman's mitt is larger than the gloves used at other positions and is shaped specifically for catching. A first baseman receives throws overwhelmingly often and has relatively few chances to throw. For that reason, the first baseman's mitt is designed to maximize the catching surface. If there were a position where "gloves on both hands" made sense, first base would probably be the closest candidate. But even a first baseman faces situations that require a throw (fielding a grounder and throwing to the pitcher, relaying on a double play, and so on), so the one-hand glove is kept. The catcher's mitt is also specialized for catching, but because the catcher must throw quickly to stop stolen bases, the one-hand glove is essential there too.
The One-Hand Glove Is the Optimal Solution for "Catching" and "Throwing"
The reason a baseball glove is worn on only one hand is not a single reason but the result of several factors overlapping. The need to throw, the lid function of the bare hand, the weight and size of the glove, and the course of history. All of these make the "one-hand glove" inevitable. Baseball is a sport that switches between "catching" and "throwing" at high speed, and the speed of this switch decides wins and losses. The asymmetric equipment of a glove on one hand and a bare hand on the other is the optimal solution for making this switch as fast as possible. Wearing gloves on both hands might make catching easier, but the price would be slower throws and no lid, and as a result the performance of the defense as a whole would decline. The one-hand glove is a design that optimizes the entire set of defensive movements in baseball.